Wednesday, May 17, 2006

Open Letter on Immigration

This is an open letter from Alex Tabarrok (GMU, Independent Institute). The link also provides valuable references on this issue.

"Dear President George W. Bush and All Members of Congress:
People from around the world are drawn to America for its promise of freedom and opportunity. That promise has been fulfilled for the tens of millions of immigrants who came here in the twentieth century.
Throughout our history as an immigrant nation, those who are already here worry about the impact of newcomers. Yet, over time, immigrants have become part of a richer America, richer both economically and culturally. The current debate over immigration is a healthy part of a democratic society, but as economists and other social scientists we are concerned that some of the fundamental economics of immigration are too often obscured by misguided commentary.
Overall, immigration has been a net gain for existing American citizens, though a modest one in proportion to the size of our 12 trillion-dollar economy.
Immigrants do not take American jobs. The American economy can create as many jobs as there are workers willing to work so long as labor markets remain free, flexible and open to all workers on an equal basis.
Immigration in recent decades of low-skilled workers may have lowered the wages of domestic low-skilled workers, but the effect is likely to be small, with estimates of wage reductions for high-school dropouts ranging from eight percent to as little as zero percent.
While a small percentage of native-born Americans may be harmed by immigration, vastly more Americans benefit from the contributions that immigrants make to our economy, including lower consumer prices. As with trade in goods and services, the gains from immigration outweigh the losses. The effect of all immigration on low-skilled workers is very likely positive as many immigrants bring skills, capital and entrepreneurship to the American economy.
Legitimate concerns about the impact of immigration on the poorest Americans should not be addressed by penalizing even poorer immigrants. Instead, we should promote policies, such as improving our education system that enables Americans to be more productive with high-wage skills.
We must not forget that the gains to immigrants from coming to the United States are immense. Immigration is the greatest anti-poverty program ever devised. The American dream is a reality for many immigrants who not only increase their own living standards but who also send billions of dollars of their money back to their families in their home countries—a form of truly effective foreign aid...
America is a generous and open country and these qualities make America a beacon to the world. We should not let exaggerated fears dim that beacon."

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Yesterday I heard somewhere that the inmigration debate was not about economics but the rule of law. Actually, the fence amendment in the senate was designed and supported by two lawyers:

Jeff Sessions
http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=S001141

Mel Martinez
http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=M001162

We have seen lately cases were ideology was stronger than facts in US politics. So, what do you think? Are these guys just being hypocritical or are they representative of ideology-driven americans? How can economists reply to this legal argument?

You seem very interested on inmigration but you haven't written your own opinion? What do you think is going to happen?

Congrats for your PhD, when will you come back to Washington?

James Baker said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Hi, Nice stuff. I found a cool news widget for our blogs at www.widgetmate.com. Now I can show the latest news on my blog. Worked like a breeze.